Search
Tickets Lineup
Riot Fest
  • Back to top
  • RIOT FEST
    • CHICAGO • SEPT 11-13, 2020
    • Tickets
    • Lockers
    • Photos
    • Past Lineups
  • Magazine
    • Most Recent
    • Features
    • Interviews
    • Music
    • TV+Film
    • Comics
  • Shows
  • Merch
  • Newsletter
  • Search

Taylor Swift Wins Copyright Lawsuit Because The Lyrics are “Too Unoriginal and Uncreative”

By Riot Fest / February 15, 2018February 15, 2018 / Music News


Last year, songwriters Sean Hall and Nathan Butler slammed Taylor Swift with a copyright lawsuit, alleging that America’s sweetheart nicked elements from the chorus of “Playas Gon’ Play” — a jam they wrote for 3LW — for use in her hit song, “Shake it Off.” According to the BBC, a judge has just ruled in Tay-Sway’s favor, dismissing the suit and garnering yet another victory for the 10-time Grammy winner.

Let’s compare. Swift sings:

Cause the players gonna play, play, play, play, play
And the haters gonna hate, hate, hate, hate, hate (haters gonna hate)

While the original 3LW song goes as such:

Playas, they gonna play
And haters, they gonna hate

You make the call!

Since it’s not your decision to make, let’s read an excerpt from Judge Michael W. Fitzgerald’s ruling, which could very well be a pull quote from the Onion if we didn’t know any better:

The lynchpin of this entire case is thus whether or not the lyrics “Playas, they gonna play, and haters, they gonna hate’ are eligible for protection. In the early 2000s, popular culture was adequately suffused with the concepts of players and haters to render the phrases “playas… gonna play” or “haters… gonna hate,” standing on their own, no more creative than “runners gonna run,” “drummers gonna drum,” or “swimmers gonna swim.”

The concept of actors acting in accordance with their essential nature is not at all creative; it is banal.

The allegedly infringed lyrics are short phrases that lack the modicum of originality and creativity required for copyright protection.

In sum, the lyrics at issue… are too brief, unoriginal, and uncreative to warrant protection under the Copyright Act.

Technically, Taylor Swift won the lawsuit, but did she really?

The decision, which has led to some seriously bad blood, will be appealed by Hall and Butler.


 

3LW Taylor Swift The Law

SHARE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Email
Riot Fest

Punk Rock (& more) Music Fest | I'm sorry we didn't book the exact bands you wanted, in the exact order you wanted, in the exact location you wanted, for free.

  • Website
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram

  • Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Instagram (Opens in new window)
  • Email Newsletter (Opens in new window)
  • Youtube (Opens in new window)
  • Reddit (Opens in new window)

Riot Fest Tickets

  • Riot Fest Tickets

Riot Fest Presents Shows

Riot Fest Presents Shows
December 12, 2019
Bottom Lounge
A Balloon Called Moaning - Ten Years Floating TourThe Joy Formidable A Balloon Called Moaning - Ten Years Floating Tour

The Joy Formidable

The Joy Formidable

The Joy Formidable

Tickets(Opens in new window).
The Joy Formidable
December 12, 2019
Chop Shop
(Thursday) The Lawrence Arms’ 5th Annual War On Xmas

(Thursday) The Lawrence Arms’ 5th Annual War On Xmas

(Thursday) The Lawrence Arms’ 5th Annual War On Xmas

(Thursday) The Lawrence Arms’ 5th Annual War On Xmas

The Flatliners

Storytime Q & A with Mike Park

Tickets(Opens in new window).
(Thursday) The Lawrence Arms’ 5th Annual War On Xmas
December 13, 2019
Chop Shop
(Friday) The Lawrence Arms’ 5th Annual War On Xmas

(Friday) The Lawrence Arms’ 5th Annual War On Xmas

(Friday) The Lawrence Arms’ 5th Annual War On Xmas

(Friday) The Lawrence Arms’ 5th Annual War On Xmas

Red City Radio

Arms Aloft

SOLD OUT
(Friday) The Lawrence Arms’ 5th Annual War On Xmas
December 14, 2019
Chop Shop
(Saturday) The Lawrence Arms’ 5th Annual War On Xmas

(Saturday) The Lawrence Arms’ 5th Annual War On Xmas

(Saturday) The Lawrence Arms’ 5th Annual War On Xmas

(Saturday) The Lawrence Arms’ 5th Annual War On Xmas

Riverboat Gamblers

Heart & Lung

Tickets(Opens in new window).
(Saturday) The Lawrence Arms’ 5th Annual War On Xmas
December 15, 2019
Cobra Lounge
Riverboat Gamblers & Red City Radio

Riverboat Gamblers & Red City Radio

Riverboat Gamblers & Red City Radio

Riverboat Gamblers & Red City Radio

Kali Masi

Tickets(Opens in new window).
Riverboat Gamblers & Red City Radio
December 15, 2019
Bottom Lounge
Boston Manor

Boston Manor

Boston Manor

Boston Manor

Microwave

Heart Attack Man

Selfish Things

Tickets(Opens in new window).
Boston Manor

MORE SHOWS

Greatest Hits

  • The Riot Fest Staff Would Like to Mail You a Holiday Card
  • The Ho Ho Haul Returns: Win Riot Fest Deluxe Tickets, 25 Vinyl LPs, And More
  • That One Time Ganser Got Attacked by Bees at Riot Fest

Sign up for our email list or my boss is going to yell at me.

  • Riot Fest Foundation
  • History
  • Privacy
  • Contact
©2019 Riot Fest
All Rights Reserved
  • Facebook (opens new window)
  • Twitter (opens new window)
  • Instagram (opens new window)
  • Youtube (opens new window)